“I can see what you mean, it just takes me longer…”
comics and animation, everyday glory, family and friends, geekery, movies and TV, news and info, The Covet List, toys May 16th, 2009Friday: Coda
Earth was good. It runs for ninety minutes and follows the journeys of three animal families: Polar bears, elephants and whales. The imagery is stunning and deserving to be seen on the big screen.
On the ride home, SaraRules and I decided to (finally) break open the Planet Earth DVDs that she got me a few months back. We started with the first DVD, first episode: “Pole to Pole.” We were a little stunned to see footage that looked incredibly similar to some that we had just seen at the theatre. After that happened a couple more times, I consulted IMDb and discovered something: Planet Earth and Earth are, more or less, the same thing, with a couple of differences. Basically, Disneynature is simply distributing Earth in the U.S., as it has been released in other countries as long as two years ago, by other local distributors. Other things I learned:
- Richard Attenborough narrated the original BBC version of Planet Earth, which is the version we own).
- Sigourney Weaver narrated the version which aired on The Discovery Channel, which is what we originally saw.
- There are (at least) three narrators for Disneynature’s Earth:
- James Earl Jones, in the U.S.
- Patrick Stewart, in the U.K.
- Ulrich Tukur, in the German version
- The narration for Earth uses much/most of the text from Planet Earth.
- Earth “changes”/creates some of the story of the animal family seen in Planet Earth. Specifically, when discussing the polar bears – there are references to a father and his journey in Earth… that aren’t seen in Planet Earth…. or, at least not in the part we’ve seen.
- Earth simplifies some of the narration, making it a little more accessible to families and children, whereas Planet Earth takes a more scientific, “here is why/how this happens” approach.
On the whole, am I upset that we spent money to see Earth? No. As I said in the opening paragraph: It deserves to be seen on the big screen. And, I enjoyed it enough to recommend others to see it in the theatre as well. If it helps, think of Earth as a prelude or teaser to the more in-depth coverage provided on the Planet Earth DVDs.
After the movie, SaraRules and I headed to coffee. We hung out with some of the usual suspects, but were surprised, pleasantly so, to see Victoria and Jim (her father/Jess’ stepfather) come in a little while later. Coffee was good. Following that, some of us went to Applebee’s for dinner. Shannon, our normal waitress, had prepared something for us: A framed copy of Jess’ obituary. It was very sweet of her. After giving it to us, she asked what had happened and how — all she had known was that Jess was “sick,” but not to what degree; we gave her a rundown of the past few months. The company of friends was good, very good indeed.
Stray Toasters
- There is a new addition – or four – to The Covet List.
- Airman Spots Jetliner Fuel Leak at 35,000 Feet
- Girl Scouts have a Comics badge!
- Open Letter to J.J. Abrams About the Star Trek Sequel
Time to call it a night.
Namaste.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.